Why is my period experience different from every other menstruator I talk to? Is that normal?

Honestly, it great that you're even having those conversations comparing periods because that is exactly what August is trying to do - to educate and get those open conversations happening. If you are experiencing pain or irregularities very often, or having pain that lasts for more than 2-3 days, go see a doctor just to check in. Everyone's body is slightly different so it is common to have slightly different symptoms, but remember, severe pain is NOT normal.